UPDATED: Man Killed by Deputies Was a Victim, Not the Suspect, LASD Says

New details emerge about the Monday night incident in West Hollywood, where three men were held at knifepoint.

Los Angeles County Sheriff's deputies shot and killed a victim of a man they believe was holding him at knifepoint. Patch file photo.
Los Angeles County Sheriff's deputies shot and killed a victim of a man they believe was holding him at knifepoint. Patch file photo.

Originally posted at 2:22 p.m. April 10, 2014. Edited with new details.

The man shot and killed by Los Angeles County Sheriff’s deputies at a West Hollywood apartment on Monday was not the suspect, but a victim being held at knifepoint, deputies said today.

Deputies have in custody Alexander McDonald, 27, whom the Los Angeles County District’s Attorney’s Office has charged with one count of murder, two counts of attempted murder and one count of torture. He pleaded not guilty today and is due back in court May 8.

Dead is John Winkler, 30, of West Hollywood. A family representative told Patch that he moved to the area just last year after graduating from the Seattle Film Institute with dreams of a career in Hollywood. City News Service reported Winkler had recently been hired as a producer on the television comedy Tosh.0.

In earlier press releases, Winkler -- unnamed at the time -- was described as the suspect.

In a press release, the sheriff’s department describe in detail the incident, which took place at 9:29 p.m. on Monday in the 900 block of Palm Avenue.

The call came in as an “assault with a deadly weapon, man with a knife,” the release says. Informants told the deputies there were two males residing in the apartment and described the suspect as a male, white, thin build, wearing a black shirt. 

As deputies prepared to make entry outside the apartment door, two men came stumbling out. The first was “covered in blood and bleeding profusely from the neck,” the release says.

Following him was Winkler, deputies say, making a “lunging” motion. Winkler fit the general description informants had given and he was wearing a black shirt.

“Believing Winkler was the assailant and the assault was ongoing and he would attack the entry team; three deputies fired their duty weapons at him,” the press release says. “Victim Winkler was struck by the gunfire and fell to the floor, and the [first] male victim also collapsed; struck once by the gunfire.”

Inside, deputies discovered two more men on the floor in a struggle.

Deputies believed McDonald had overpowered the victim and was allegedly choking and tearing at his face, officials said.

“The victim was about to go unconscious and a large knife was on the floor near them. The deputies were able to use physical force to subdue the suspect and end the assault,” the news release says. “The suspect was taken into custody without further incident.”

The Winkler family representative, who asked not to be named, said he didn’t live with McDonald, but the two were friends. He and some buddies got a call that night that McDonald was “acting crazy” and needed help.

Winkler and his friends were just “trying to calm Alex down,” said Winkler’s relative.

Homicide detectives believe that instead, McDonald held his friends captive while “in a rage.”

The victim who stumbled through the door first and was shot in the leg while deputies took aim at Winkler is in stable condition, the sheriff’s department reports.

The victim from inside the apartment, who suffered stab wounds to the face, legs and chest, has been treated for his injuries and released, according to the department.

McDonald’s bail has been set at $4 million. 

City News Service contributed to this report.

Shaye April 11, 2014 at 07:22 PM
disgusting behavior... U cannot even call the cops when U really need them now?? They r definitely not here to protect and serve anymore.. and why not use a TASER?? ESP when the suspect has a knife and not a gun.. they went from shooting family pets to now innocent victims of a crime.... ALL 3 of the dipshits need desk jobs b/c they have NO idea how to do their job.. pathetic
George April 12, 2014 at 12:46 PM
I fully agree with Shayne. The police men harass me all the time. While taking a leisurely bike ride just recently, I was pulled over by a police man for not having a bike light. It was barely dark outside. He handcuffed me and frisked me and then proceed to search my back pack taking it fully apart. They kept asking me if I was a drug addict or on parole. I told then I was a resident of the community taking a bike ride. They ran my drivers license and uncuffed me and said I can go. I was mortified by the experience. All my neighbors watched as I was treated like a criminal. VERY embarrassing! I won't go bike riding in WH anymore. I scared the police will harass or shot me like they did that poor sweet man. Why is it that the city council members in West Hollywood are not addressing these actions and demanding these police men are reprimanded or fired for abuse of power/murder? The new mayor of Los Angeles needs to also address this because it is not just here in West Hollywood it is happening all throughout Los Angeles and it needs to stop. How many people have to be murdered for not reason before action is taken? Gays are so busy going on and on about silly gay marriage mean while our people are being murdered and/or harassed by law enforcement. Make absolutely no sense whatsoever! Get your priority straight gays!
Shaye April 14, 2014 at 03:59 PM
^ wow... unbelievable to be harassed for not having lights on your bike.. and handcuffed 4 it??? wow... bullies with power!!! arrgg... sorry u had to go thru that!!! and thanks for agreeing with me!!! n No N in my name..lol.... <3
George April 14, 2014 at 04:58 PM
The police are corrupt in most cities. It Fullerton they beat a homeless man to death and got away with it. Just last night a homeless man was shot to death in Hollywood. We need police personnel that understand they work for the folks to protect us not harass or kill us.
Penny Arévalo April 14, 2014 at 05:01 PM
You can find out about that story here: http://hollywood.patch.com/groups/police-and-fire/p/officers-shoot-at-suspect-with-knife-in-east-hollywood


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »